The Cardinal Electors, Then and Now

First Things, 6 May 2025

A conclave constructed by the late Holy Father to exclude Patriarch Shevchuk is one less likely to be an instrument of the Holy Spirit.

Does a conclave elect the man the Holy Spirit desires to lead the Church? History teaches that sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn’t. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger’s view was that too many poor popes have been elected to say that the man who emerges is always God’s choice. At the same time, the Holy Spirit, in Ratzinger’s memorable phrase, offers the “assurance . . . that the thing cannot be totally ruined.”

The Holy Spirit does not get a vote in the conclave. The cardinals elect the pope, and no one else. The more apt question then is whether this particular conclave is likely to be an instrument of the Holy Spirit, knowing of course that even Balaam’s ass can speak should God so will it (Num. 22:21–35).

At 133 electors, it is the largest conclave in history. Quantitatively big, it has enormous geographic reach, from Mongolia to Madagascar, but not Montreal or Milan. Quantity, though, is not as important as quality.

A contrast is illustrative. The twin conclaves of 1978 elected two popes, both of whom took the name John Paul. It is evident now that the second John Paul was God’s choice, but that the cardinals could not initially see their way to electing a fifty-eight-year-old non-Italian, so they first got it not exactly wrong, but not exactly right either, electing Cardinal Albino Luciani. Then the Holy Spirit did cast his vote, and Blessed John Paul I was dead thirty-three days later. 

How might, qualitatively, the electors of 1978 compare to those of 2025? In 1978, the leading theological light in the conclave was Joseph Ratzinger of Munich, created a cardinal only the year before. Last year, Pope Francis added Timothy Radcliffe, O.P., to the College of Cardinals, a former master of the Dominican order whose term ended a quarter-century ago amidst deep misgivings about his theological orthodoxy. Many cardinal electors would likely not permit Cardinal Radcliffe to preach a retreat to their own priests.

In 1978, the heroic head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, the living martyr Cardinal Josyf Slipyj, was in Rome but not eligible to vote due to his age. His presence, though, reminded the electors of the persecuted Church. 

In 2025, Patriarch Sviatoslav Shevchuk, perhaps the most outstanding bishop in the Catholic Church these past dozen years, is also in Rome these weeks. He is not part of the conclave, as Pope Francis refused to make him a cardinal—as were his predecessors—in ten straight consistories. There are few outside the papal household who think that this deliberate dishonoring of Ukrainian Catholics was of the Holy Spirit. A conclave constructed by the late Holy Father to exclude Shevchuk is one less likely to be an instrument of the Holy Spirit. 

In 1978, one of the greatest bishops of the twentieth century, Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński, primate of Poland, was present. His cardinal titular church was Santa Maria in Trastevere, the same title once held by Cardinal James Gibbons of Baltimore. Wyszyński was the lion that stood up to the Soviet empire. 

In 2025, another cardinal linked to that church, Matteo Zuppi of Italy, will be an elector. Santa Maria in Trastevere was taken when he was created a cardinal, so a new title was fashioned for him, Sant’Egidio in Trastevere. Cardinal Zuppi has been the papal envoy for the Ukrainian war, visiting both Moscow and Beijing. He does not have the spirit of Blessed Stefan Wyszyński.

In 1978, there was a cardinal from the capital region of Argentina who had been called to curial service. Cardinal Eduardo Pironio was formerly the bishop of Mar del Plata, and was serving as prefect of religious in 1978. He would later, as president of the Council for the Laity, become something of a father of the World Youth Days, the first of which outside of Rome was held in Buenos Aires in 1987. Pironio was beatified in 2023. 

In 2025, Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, prefect of doctrine, is from the same capital region of Argentina, appointed early on by Pope Francis to be archbishop of La Plata. The pre-elevation writings of Cardinal Fernández—leaving aside his curial service entirely—would disqualify any cause of his from consideration by the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints.

Continue reading at First Things.